Both did give it a 9.5, there is good and bad in both reviews. The Multiplayer is definatly where its at with H3. From what I can gather between both reviews and rumblings across the WWW, Graphics and Sound are second to none and Multiplayer and the Forge will keep this up at the top for years to come.
Its an impossibility for any developer to please 100% of every gamer, so it doesn't suprise me that Multiplayer got such high marks and the Storyline, was just so-so. MP allows for diversed gameplay set almost never playing the same exact game twice and with the ability to make changes and such via forge, Bungie/MS has opened up a wonderfull can for all of us gamers.
