THE CLASH OF CUDI

F

Fillyy

Banned
1st version is better IMO. It seems like an experimental tag to me, like its something that you wouldnt use as a style, but rather something that you made for fun to see how it turned out.
 
C

ChangeOfMandate

New member
Thats not going to be in a text book. Not candy, correct, but at least give the guy something positive to work with. By being harsh you make people feel discouraged. make sure you let them know something specificly good. "you can get better" doesnt point out what they should or shouldnt do again.

When you tell them bad things, its not the same as telling them to keep it up and not as effective as showing them good techniques.
 
The Big Tickett

The Big Tickett

Banned
Ok lol this topic is so wrong. I agree with Swift personally. Double focals are rarely good. Stay away from them. Fix the colors. They are bad both versions. If your wanting a ranking then NOVICE is what that tag is. I'm sorry but this tag is not great by any means. Sorry if I sound like a jerk but yall are all arguing too so I'm not the only one :p Oh ya and CnC is telling them all the bad stuff. You can say good stuff if you want but thats not helping them at all.
 
X

XGC LilOwl

New member
@ Swift

Please allow me to Quote Tyme for you. since you obviously haven't read his thread...

Be honest. There is nothing worse then saying something is great, when it's not. Honest feedback will ultimately help you to give a good critique.
Be detailed in your assessment. When giving feedback, draw on your design vocabulary to help you articulate why you felt the work was not successful. The more detail you can give, the better. It helps your peer understand where his or her work went wrong.

Offer constructive criticism. Don't be mean when reviewing someone's work. People can very sensitive about their work, and when you are criticizing something they may have spent days working on, it is very easy for them to take it personally. As you critique, try to offer solutions. Suggest ways that they can correct the misstep. This is the most rewarding thing to do, as not only are you aiding a peer in their work, but you are pushing your own creativity to come up with creative solutions to a problem. Creative problem solving is major facet of design.

Be open minded. Just because your peer's style may be different from your own does not mean it is bad. You need be open to other solutions to a problem.

Ask questions. Don't be afraid to ask your peers questions about what the work means or what they were trying to say. Also, when accepting criticism, do not be content with simple one word comments. If someone offers his or her opinion and you do not understand it, ask for clarification -- get to the heart of what they were trying to say.
Click to expand...

Don't believe me, please http://www.xiledgaming.com/forum/showthread.php?t=65728

Maybe you should take a good read at the rules before just going off like a jerk. Because what you're doing, is NOT constructive.

You're of course honest, brutally at that.
But you are not being constructive, you're just arguing to make yourself seem right.
IMO, I'm seeing no open mindedness what so ever...
and, uh, I'm totally sure you're not asking questions. you're just trying to be right.
 
X

XDC Swagg

New member
Alrighty again; I mistook this CNC for a drama-fest, yet again! Lawlz; as the moderator, you need to close the thread down. Leaving the thread open is causing the creation of further drama. Xiled Gaming is a community made up of professionals; not those partcipating in a drama-fest.
 
C

ChangeOfMandate

New member
We're no pros, perfect. Don't need to lie.

This thread is straightened out, don't worry about it. IF you post more about drama here, you'll just start it up again.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top