This looks good. I'm loving this, excellent work!
This...not so much.
I'm going to be honest with you Dragon. I see some of your work and I'm like, "WHOA! This guy is spot on! Let's accept him!!" And then I see other signatures and I'm just like, "What went wrong?! The last one was so amazing Q.Q"
You have a lot of potential. I can see it in about 40% of your designs. The other 60% are lacking. So let's see what we can do to get that 40% up to 100%!
On the first signature, you have great flow, lighting, depth, blending and coloring. I'm loving it. It's fun, you have effects throughout the whole design and I don't think that they're too distracting. It's just great! The only thing i'd say needs improving is the text. But text is very difficult to get a grasp on. I even still struggle with text. >.< You also have a great use of your Rule-of-Thirds. I have absolutely no CnC for that signature.
Then I look at the 2nd signature...
There is no blending at all.
There is no flow
There is no depth
The colors are off. Your render is green, you background is like the crayon box puked on it. =(
There is no lighting
The effects are poor quality as is the background.
Just overall a bad design.
I think you need a different approach with this stock image.
I think that the background is giving you a bad start, so let's soften it to give you a good starting place. You can do this from smudge, blurring, cloning or a mixture of all three. I personally like blurring, but we can do it with smudging as well. For a blur, i would take the stock, duplicate it to a new layer and apply a Gaussian blur. Then i would take my soft brush and with an opacity of about 45 and erase over the focal a few time until i got a soft background, but my focal was clear.
But for this image, since the rain is a really had white, a blur wont work very well. This will require some smudging.
Here is what I came up with.
Now, I only took the lines out of the top of the focal. You'll have to spend a little more time working it out.
You'll also notice that I put the X over the image. This is because I don't want to do the work for you, i want to teach you so you're better equipped to work with images like these in the future. =)
If you find yourself just absolutely struggling with getting a good base from this image, then let me know and if i can't assist you any further, than i'll take the watermark off and let you use this for your signature. But I have faith that you can do it!
A 3rd option would be to render the focal completely, but i think this smudging will be efficient.